ABC’s “The Good Doctor”

Those who have read my previous writings will know that I have been critical of Autism portrayals in Hollywood. Grey’s Anatomy’s Dr. Virginia Dixon was (in my view) the worst of any Hollywood portrayal I have ever seen. I am convinced the writers based her representation on a list of symptoms from WebMD and an article about Dr. Temple Grandin. I suppose you could say that I was “triggered” by Dr. Dixon’s evident inability to recognize when the parents of a brain-dead patient might not want to be overwhelmed with all of the details as to why their beloved daughter’s life has been cut short.

Multiple publications have praised a new ABC drama titled “The Good Doctor” as a program which sheds light on Autism. The show’s protagonist is Dr. Shaun Murphy (Freddie Highmore.) He is a surgeon who lives with Autistic Spectrum Disorder. Some articles have indicated that he also has Savant syndrome. The first five episodes of the series have made it abundantly clear that Shaun lived a troubled childhood. His father was an abusive alcoholic. His brother was tragically killed in a fall from the roof of a train car, which he and his friends were playing on. 

It is encouraging to see a positive depiction of someone who lives with a neurological condition which affects no two people in exactly the same way. I am not at all denying that people are becoming more educated and aware that Autism is real. I am genuinely grateful for the many folks who continue to fight the good fight. I am also thankful for the writer’s attempt to convey a message that it is possible for someone who is on the Autism Spectrum to pursue a successful career in a field they are passionate about. 

That being said, I can see why some people take issue with Hollywood portrayals of Autism. It all goes back to the clear difference between fantasy and reality. Hollywood loves to misrepresent neurological disorders. A high paying job like one held by Freddie Highmore’s character is merely a fantasy for many people who have an ASD. I’ve read horror stories about employers who were far from willing to make accommodations based on the person’s needs. 

Hollywood’s continued support Autism Speaks is another primary reason why some take issue with the film and television industry’s representations of the disorder. The fact is, this organization does little to nothing with regards to providing real support for individuals and their families. Their primary focus is on the highly controversial search for a cure. They primarily cater towards families with children and provide little to no support for adults. ASD does not end after high school. It is a lifelong struggle with its own set of challenges in every phase of the individual’s life. 

As stated in an earlier paragraph, there are some high points to the character that is Dr. Shaun Murphy. However, my biggest complaint thus far would be the scenes where they portray Shaun as someone with apparent social ineptitude. I can partially forgive it because he had a troubled childhood and lacked an adult figure who could teach him proper social boundaries. I am currently willing to trust the writers will not go the route of portraying him as a man who somehow thinks his diagnosis automatically entitles him to a get out of jail free card when people call him out on social behavior which violates necessary boundaries. 

(The episode “Pipes” proves my point. Shaun wakes up his landlord after midnight to give him a list of repairs to be done around his apartment.) 

There are a few things I would like to see in future episodes of “The Good Doctor.” I know several people who work in hospitals. One must have a thick skin and be able to cope with any situation that can cause stress. My question is, how would a character like Shaun respond to a crisis situation in the hospital? An answer to that question would most likely depend on what type of crisis I am referring to. Any kind of situation which disrupts the typical day to day operations of the fictional St. Bonaventure hospital would give us a glimpse into how Shaun reacts to stressful situations which disrupt his routine. 

All in all, I do look forward to seeing more episodes of The Good Doctor. I think Shaun is a likable character with tremendous potential as a surgeon. I hope the writers, and fans of this show, will take my above concerns into account. 



8 thoughts on “ABC’s “The Good Doctor”

  1. I asked you when the show first premiered if you saw it and, if so, what your opinion was. I enjoy the series but, I knew your opinion would let me know if they were doing a good job or not.


  2. Joseph:

    I would also make a “Good Doctor #actuallyautistic” Google alert or whatever alerting / notifications you make.

    For me, Derek is one of many opinions I would consider before my Good Doctor was informed.

    Stressful situations which disrupt the routine – this is a crucial point.

    And at least sometimes the detail cuts and sticks through.

    Thank you for being so clear about the brother’s death and concise.

    And if the landlord were in somewhere between Apia and Montreal?


    • I wanted Derek’s opinion on the show because, I respect him and think he is a really good person. I wanted to know if the way Autism was portrayed was in his opinion was a true to the Autism Spectrum or if it offended him. I am a fan of Freddie Highmore since Bates Motel but, I am not really a fan of hospital dramas. Since I have medical issues of my own, it’s something I would rather escape from when I take the time to relax and watch a TV show, see a movie or read a book.


      • Thank you again, Joseph.

        I think Derek is a good person too.

        I’ve been a Highmore fan for quite a while. Since FINDING NEVERLAND and probably NANNY McPHEE.

        Yes – it’s good to get away from medical stuff when we have medical issues of our own.

        And sometimes the escape hatch is broken, like when a show is not well-written or over-written.


      • I watched the first 3 episodes of The Good Doctor but, I just didn’t want to deal with the operations scenes and the medical talk since. I didn’t know Freddie Highmore was in Finding Neverland. or Nanny McPhee. I didn’t see either one even though I worked for Miramax films at the time they released Finding Neverland. I’ll have to check them out. I thought he did a great job with Norman Bates, a character so associated with Anthony Perkins.


  3. Joseph:

    what did you do at Miramax Films?

    And of course this was in the early 2000s.

    I don’t remember much medical *talk* per se in the third episode of THE GOOD DOCTOR which I had just watched on Tuesday.

    As it turns out Highmore was not in NANNY McPHEE.

    And Norman Bates does require a special portrayer.

    I think more of the directorship; lighting; music and other stagecraft elements when it comes to PSYCHO.


    • I was the assistant to Harvey Weinstein’s assistant. Harvey would tell his assistant what he wanted and his assistant had me do it. I loved the job. I’ve always been a big movie fan and there I was part of the industry. Harvey was very demanding but, very respectful if you did your job right. All this sexual abuse stuff was a surprise to me and made me sad even though I now think of him as a horrible person.
      I always look at movies from a technical point of few too. Like you would look at a painting. How everything is put together to make a good work of art or fail to make a good work of art. Highmore had a difficult job to do portraying a character so related to Anthony Perkins portrayal. Highmore did a good job.


      • Getting back to The Good Doctor, I’m more interested in how they are portraying autism that’s why I ask Derek what he thought of the show. As I said, I really don’t like watching hospital dramas.


Leave Me A Comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s